Skip to content
Menu Ice Cream Events Catering Visit
Order
Menu Ice Cream Events Gallery Catering Visit FAQ En español Order online

The full menu

Coffee, ice cream and cocktails in downtown Greeley.

Espresso and drip from Wander Coffee Roasters, Dole soft serve, Blue Bell scoops, breakfast and 21+ cocktails. Prices before tax, current as of September 2026.

Order online Ice cream menu
Coffee Not coffee Ice cream Food 21+ Take home Add-ons

Coffee

Limited time

Autumn Specials

Fall 2026, limited time. Most drinks hot or iced.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • Caramel Apple Chai
    5.75 / 6.50 / 7.25
  • Orange Clove Cold Brew Tonic
    5.50 / 6.25 / 7.00
  • Pumpkin Spice Latte
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Salted Maple Latte
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Brown Sugar FreddoWhipped espresso with brown sugar and a splash of half and half.
    16 oz 5.50
  • “Bobbing for Apples”Original Red Bull with caramel and apple.
    16 oz 5.25
  • Pumpkin Spice Coffee MilkshakePumpkin sauce, espresso, vanilla ice cream, nutmeg and cinnamon.
    12 oz 6.75 / 16 oz 9.75

Coffee

Hot or iced. Decaf available. Proudly serving Wander Coffee Roasters.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • Drip Coffee
    3.00 / 3.75 / 4.50
  • Americano2, 3 or 4 shots by size.
    4.00 / 4.75 / 5.50
  • Latte2, 3 or 4 shots by size.
    4.50 / 5.25 / 6.00
  • CappuccinoAlso in 8 oz, $4.00.
    4.50 / 5.25 / 6.00
  • Cold Brew
    4.75 / 5.50 / 6.25
  • FrappeBlended and iced.
    5.50 / 6.50 / 7.50
  • Cortado
    4.00
  • Double ShotStraight espresso.
    2.50

Specialty Lattes

Iced, hot, or blended.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • The ClassicVanilla and caramel
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Café MielHoney and cinnamon
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Mexican MochaChocolate, cinnamon, cayenne, nutmeg
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Forever SpringLavender and vanilla
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Berries and CreamBlackberry, strawberry, white chocolate
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75
  • Nutty ClusterHazelnut, almond, chocolate
    5.25 / 6.00 / 6.75

Not coffee

Tea

Hot or iced.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • Loose Leaf TeaEarl Grey, English Breakfast, jasmine, Moroccan mint, sencha, rooibos chai, peppermint and more.
    3.50 / 4.25 / 5.00
  • Tea Latte
    4.50 / 5.25 / 6.00
  • London FogEarl Grey tea latte.

Not Coffee

Hot or iced.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • House Chai
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50
  • Matcha Latte
    4.75 / 5.50 / 6.25
  • Turmeric LatteGolden milk.
    4.75 / 5.50 / 6.25
  • Apple Cider
    4.00 / 4.75 / 5.50
  • Hot ChocolateAlso in 8 oz, $4.00.
    4.50 / 5.00 / 5.50
  • SteamerAlso in 8 oz, $3.25.
    3.75 / 4.25 / 4.75
  • Fountain SodaPepsi, Starry, Orange Soda, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper
    3.00 / 3.75 / 4.50
  • Italian SodaYour flavor with sparkling water, with or without cream.
    4.25 / 5.00 / 5.75
  • Sparkling Watermelon Mint RefresherWatermelon and cucumber mint with sparkling water.
    4.50 / 5.25 / 6.00

Dirty Sodas

Make it a float for $2.50 more.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • SPF 15Dr. Pepper, raspberry, coconut cream
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50
  • Strawberry FizzPepsi, strawberry, vanilla cream
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50
  • Orange CreamsicleOrange soda, white chocolate, vanilla cream
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50
  • ButterbeerRoot beer, hazelnut, vanilla cream
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50
  • Peachy ColadaStarry, peach, coconut cream
    5.00 / 5.75 / 6.50

Lemonade

Iced, blended, or sparkling. Add a flavor for $0.75, or make it a Palmer.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • LemonadePeach, blackberry, raspberry, strawberry, lavender, blueberry, coconut, cherry or matcha.
    3.50 / 4.25 / 5.00

Smoothies

Add-ins: protein, banana, chia seeds, matcha, turmeric.

12 oz16 oz20 oz

  • SmoothieStrawberry, peach, mango or guava coconut.
    5.00 / 6.00 / 7.00

Bottled + Canned

  • Red BullOriginal, Sugarfree, Tropical, Watermelon or Coconut.
    4.00
  • PoppiCherry Limeade, Strawberry Lemon or Orange.
    3.00
  • Liquid DeathStill Mountain Water, Arnold Palmer, Berry It Alive or Lime.
    4.00
  • MOR KombuchaCherry Limeade, Hazy Cactus or Mojito.
    4.50
  • IBCRoot Beer or Cream Soda.
    5.00
  • Canned SodaPepsi, Diet Pepsi or Dr. Pepper.
    3.00
  • Orange Juice
    3.00
  • Bottled Water
    2.00

Ice cream

Soft Serve

Dole pineapple soft serve while supplies last.

2 twists4 twists

  • Dole Pineapple
    5.00 / 7.00
  • Vanilla
    5.00 / 7.00
  • Pineapple + Vanilla Twist
    5.00 / 7.00

Blue Bell Ice Cream

Hard-dip ice cream. Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, coconut and black cherry. Flavors may rotate.

HalfSingleDouble

  • Scoops
    4.00 / 5.50 / 7.50

Sorbet

Rotating flavor.

HalfSingleDouble

  • Sorbet Scoops
    3.00 / 4.50 / 6.50

Specialty Ice Cream

  • Banana SplitVanilla and chocolate with banana, whipped cream, hot fudge, sprinkles and maraschino cherries.
    2 scoops 9.75 / 3 scoops 12.25
  • The MixiSoft serve blended thick with your choice of mix-ins.
    9.00
  • MilkshakeVanilla, chocolate, strawberry, coffee, matcha or chai.
    12 oz 6.00 / 16 oz 9.00
  • FloatSoda, cold brew, chai, matcha or iced tea. Cold brew, chai or matcha add $1.
    12 oz 6.50 / 16 oz 7.00 / 20 oz 7.50

Affogatos

  • Single AffogatoOne scoop with your choice of espresso, drip coffee, matcha, chai, Earl Grey or another tea. Decaf espresso available.
    5.75
  • Golden AffogatoVanilla bean ice cream, a drizzle of olive oil and sea salt, topped with espresso.
    5.75
  • Affogato FlightChoose three pairings, each with a half scoop and a 1.5 oz pour.
    12.00

Food

Bagel Sandwiches

Plain, everything, blueberry, cinnamon raisin or gluten-free bagel, or sliced sourdough.

  • Pesto Turkey Delight
    7.75
  • Ham & Cheese Melt
    7.50
  • Turkey Chipotle Melt
    7.50
  • Sausage Egg & Cheese
    7.50
  • Build Your OwnFrom $3.00 plus add-ons.
    from 3.00

Breakfast Burritos

Seasoned potatoes, scrambled eggs and cheddar, plus house-made verde or rojo salsa.

  • Carne Asada
    6.00
  • Bacon
    6.00
  • Potato, Egg and Cheese
    6.00
New

Avocado Toast

Sourdough, olive oil, fresh avocado, lemon juice, flaky sea salt, feta, balsamic drizzle and pea sprouts.

  • Avocado Toast
    1 slice 5.00 / 2 slices 9.50

Pastries

The case changes daily. Ask what's fresh.

  • Apple Cinnamon Muffin
    4.50
  • Cranberry Orange Muffin
    4.50
  • Banana Muffin
    4.50
  • Gluten-Free Blueberry Muffin
    5.00
  • Cherry Almond Danish
    5.50
  • Cream Cheese Danish
    5.50
  • Banana Nutella Pop Tart
    4.50
  • Nutella Cheesecake Pop Tart
    4.50
  • Chipotle Turkey Pop TartSavory.
    6.50
  • Ham, Cheese and Herb Pop TartSavory.
    6.50
  • Pesto Turkey Cream Cheese Pop TartSavory.
    6.50
  • Ham, Cheese and Herb Roll-Ups
    3.50
  • Mini Quiche
    4.50
  • Quiche Slice
    6.50
  • Strawberry Lemon Roll
    4.50
  • Mini Strawberry Cream Tart
    3.00
  • Triple Chocolate Chip Cookie
    4.50
  • S'more Cookie
    4.50
  • Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie
    2.50
  • Gluten-Free Banana Bread
    3.00
  • Brownie
    3.50

21+

Cocktails

21+. Valid ID required.

  • The Espresso MartiniHouse made syrup and fresh-pulled espresso
    12.00
  • Irish CoffeeIrish cream and Jameson in drip coffee or cold brew, iced or hot
    12.00
  • Dirty Filthy ChaiKahlua and bourbon in house made chai, iced or hot
    12.00
  • Old FashionedBourbon and orange bitters
    12.00
  • French 75Gin, prosecco, lemon juice, simple syrup
    12.00
  • Dirty ShirleyLemon lime soda, vodka, a dash of grenadine
    10.00
  • Lavender Gin LemonadeGin, lemonade, a hint of lavender
    10.00
  • Bloody MaryVodka and Zing Zang mix
    10.00
  • MimosaChampagne and orange juice
    7.00

Boozy Milkshakes

21+. Spiked and spun in house. 16 oz only.

  • Irish CoffeeCold brew, vanilla ice cream, Irish cream, Jameson, Kahlua
    16 oz 15.00
  • Peachy BourbonVanilla ice cream, peach purée, bourbon
    16 oz 14.00
  • Dirty ChaiCinnamon ice cream, chai, bourbon, Kahlua
    16 oz 15.00

Boozy Ice Cream Floats

21+. 16 oz only.

  • Irish CoffeeCold brew with Irish cream, Jameson and Kahlua, poured over vanilla bean ice cream
    16 oz 15.00
  • Summer VacationCoconut matcha with Malibu rum over strawberry ice cream
    16 oz 15.00
  • Dirty Filthy SodaPepsi with vodka, Malibu rum and grenadine over vanilla ice cream
    16 oz 13.00
  • Sorbet FloatRotating sorbet flavor and champagne
    6 oz 10.00

Beer & Wine

21+.

  • Coors Light16 oz can
    7.00
  • Juicy Bits IPA16 oz can
    8.00
  • Not Your Father's Root Beer
    7.00
  • Chardonnay
    7.00
  • Cabernet Sauvignon
    7.00
  • Prosecco
    7.00

Pours

21+.

  • Tito's Vodka
    9.00
  • Jameson
    9.00
  • Bulleit Bourbon
    9.00
  • Tequila Blanco
    9.00
  • Gin
    9.00
  • Malibu
    8.00
  • Kahlua
    7.00
  • Baileys Irish Cream
    7.00
  • Amaretto
    7.00

Take home

Coffee + Tea to Take Home

  • Spotlight BlendWhole bean.
    8 oz 9.50 / 12 oz 14.00 / 16 oz 18.00
  • Night SkyWhole bean.
    8 oz 9.50
  • DecafWhole bean.
    8 oz 9.50
  • Loose Leaf TeaBy the bag. Earl Grey, English Breakfast, jasmine, Moroccan mint, sencha, rooibos chai and more.
    from 5.00

Add-ons

Coffee Syrups

$0.75 each. Honey $0.50.

VanillaSF VanillaCaramelSF CaramelStrawberryCane SugarWhite ChocolateHoneyAgaveHazelnutPeachAlmondCoconutLavenderRaspberryBlackberryChocolateBlueberryCherryPumpkinApple

Milk + Foam

$0.75 each. Skim is free.

Oat milkAlmond milkBreveVanilla cold foam

Ice Cream Toppings

SprinklesOreosMini M&MsMini Chocolate ChipsMaraschino CherriesWhipped CreamHot FudgeCaramelReese's PiecesBrownie Pieces

Prices before tax, current as of September 2026. Sizes, add-ons and seasonal items are also on the online ordering page.

Spotlight Café & Creamery

Coffee early, ice cream late and plenty in between.

802 9th Street, Greeley, CO 80631 · (970) 836-2646 · Open daily until 10 p.m.

Same building: Moxi Theater upstairs and Stella's Pinball Arcade & Lounge.

Menu Events Gallery wall Ice cream Catering En español
Follow us